Showing reviews 1-10 of 121 | Next

1. Butterscotch Our Favorite

   Posted by Hoppy on 21st Nov 2019

   My family loves butterscotch peanut butter. It is great with apples.
   When we visit Cape May we load up on peanut butter.
   I just received a order to gift at Christmas to my family members

2. LOVE CAPE MAY PEANUT BUTTER

   Posted by JOAN QUINN on 24th Oct 2019

   A HOUSEWARMING GIFT FOR MY SON. DID NOT GIVE IT TO HIM YET. HE IS A PEANUT BUTTER EXPERT. I'M SURE HE WILL LOVE IT

3. addicted

   Posted by Unknown on 4th Oct 2019

   This stuff is so good. Not too sweet and so much better than a processed jarred store bought PB. I keep coming back for more. I love it spread on whole grain toast with banana or I even dip my sugar free dark chocolate in it as a snack.

4. This is the best flavored PB

   Posted by Nikki on 25th Sep 2019

   Ease of ordering was great and decently priced and shipping options were priced well also! Definitely will be ordering more!!!

5. Yummy

   Posted by stephanie on 23rd Sep 2019

   this has a distinct butterscotch flavor blended into a satisfying crunchy peanut butter.

6. For ButterScotch lovers, this is for you!

   Posted by bmccoy_98@yahoo.com on 28th Aug 2019

   Great tasting peanut butter for a butterscotch fan. Tends to be a little sweet but oh so good!

7. Delicious

   Posted by Candace Scott on 28th Aug 2019

   We have been purchasing the Butterscotch peanut butter since the shop opened in Cape May. Now that we have moved to Tennessee, we order it in bulk twice a year. Our neighbors and friends love to receive it as gifts and we couple it with honey from the Cape May Honey Farm on Sunset. Guaranteed to be a crowd pleasurer! We love the fact it has chocolate as one of the ingredients!

8. AWESOMENESS on a spoon!

   Posted by Unknown on 26th Aug 2019

   I bought this while on vacation, and had to quickly order more...so delicious

9. Butterscotch Peanut Butter

   Posted by rfitzgerald711@gmail.com on 15th Aug 2019

   Absolutely phenomenal! I first bought this last summer and ran out in the fall. I had to wait until this summer to order more. I have already ordered twice so I don’t run out again.

10. Amazingly delicious butterscotch peanut butter

    Posted by Unknown on 30th Jul 2019

    The butterscotch peanut butter is delicious! It's hard to just each one serving size. It's very fresh and I love purchasing from a small business.

Showing reviews 1-10 of 121 | Next