(266 reviews) Write a Review
1.25 LBS
Adding to cart… The item has been added

Our Butterscotch Peanut Butter is made with roasted peanuts and butterscotch pieces. Try spreading this on top of a piece of pound cake for a tasty snack!

266 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5

    Posted by Laura L Ketchum on 26th Sep 2022

    This is addicting. Love it!

  • 5
    Butterscotch peanut butter

    Posted by Margaret Zeiders on 21st Sep 2022

    Deliciously sweet. Great on bananas.

  • 5
    My favorite PB

    Posted by Candice Pagnotti on 25th Aug 2022

    This PB has a great natural texture, sweet to salty ratio. My go to breakfast on a rice cake or English muffin before running or on the go.

  • 5
    Butter Scotch the best

    Posted by Soe on 9th Aug 2022

    me and my daughter we finished the big jar of butter scotch in a week I was so sad it is from cape may and we are from Kearny we are almost 3 hr aways My husband said order as many as I want so I ordered 2 more biggest jar of butter scotch and 1 big honey roasted which is for my kids for me Butter Scotch is my favorite and I am in love I am recommending to all my families & friends how good it is we will be coming back soon more than 5

  • 5
    Peanut butter

    Posted by Laura Bross on 3rd Aug 2022

    This peanut butter is amazing!!

  • 5

    Posted by David Bruno on 3rd Aug 2022


  • 5
    Butterscotch Peanu tbutter

    Posted by Charlene Chiaro on 1st Aug 2022

    The most delicious peanut butter I have ever tasted!! It's a must purchase every time I'm in Cape May

  • 5
    Butterscotch "Peanut" Butter

    Posted by Dawn on 16th Jul 2022

    OMG! This stuff is like candy. I can never go back to standard peanut butter after having this. It's breakfast on toast but dessert also. So tasty!

  • 5
    Butter Scotch

    Posted by Rosemarie Merritt on 11th Jul 2022

    I am not really sure that I tasted the butterscotch in this. That doesn't necessarily mean it was bad, though. The consistency reminded me of the PB in a Reese's PB Cup (and I LOVE those!)