(197 reviews) Write a Review
1.25 LBS
Adding to cart… The item has been added

Our Butterscotch Peanut Butter is made with roasted peanuts and butterscotch pieces. Try spreading this on top of a piece of pound cake for a tasty snack!
Serving Size - 2 Tablespoons
Ingredients: Dry Roasted Peanuts, Butterscotch Drops, Brown Sugar, Natural Flavor, Soybean Oil.


197 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5

    Posted by Colleen Cantalupo on 12th Feb 2021

    This is delicious !!! I have it every morning with my honey crisp apple . I can’t say enough about the taste it is so amazing !!

  • 5
    Butterscotch peanut butter

    Posted by Robin James on 1st Feb 2021

    Have enjoyed this butterscotch peanut butter for 3 years now. All of them are great, but this one is my favorite

  • 5
    Butterscotch Peanutbutter

    Posted by Honestly, just buy it! on 1st Feb 2021

    I discovered this company, this beautiful, wonderful company, 3 years ago on a trip to Cape May. It was tucked away and I almost Didn’t notice it but my friend and I (both peanut butter lovers) darted in. I bought Every flavor and now the Butterscotch one haunts my ever waking moment with the need for more. Needless to say it is delicious and I will Consistently be a costumer till I die Or the company goes out of business!

  • 5
    Peanut Butter

    Posted by michelle derer on 27th Jan 2021

    This was my first time trying this flavor.. it will now be a regular add on to my order! Delicious!

  • 5

    Posted by Ariel on 26th Jan 2021

    This pb is soooo tasty!!! Absolutely fabulous on toast, cookies, crackers, or just by itself off a spoon. Yum yum yum.

  • 5
    Delicious Product

    Posted by Ameet Mathew on 25th Jan 2021

    Honestly tastes like I'm eating peanut butter frosting with just the right balance of smoothness and chunkiness.

  • 5
    ButterScotch Peanut Butter

    Posted by JanetD on 20th Jan 2021

    Heavenly. This peanut butter is addicting. I can't get enough. It is such a great mix of flavors. I highly recommend it.

  • 5
    Best Butterscotch taste

    Posted by J Snyder on 4th Jan 2021

    We tasted this at Cape May on vacation in 2019. I ordered it during the lockdown for a shore treat. The butterscotch is the best! I tried a different butterscotch peanut butter from a different vendor. This one is SO much better! We tried it in a traditional cookie recipe, but but the butterscotch flavor did not come through. Very good with bagels, toast, and fruit.

  • 5
    Better that Nutella

    Posted by LB on 20th Dec 2020

    I have bought the mini pb's every year for the past three years to give as gifts. Everyone absolutely loves them! They are all delicious, but the butterscotch is always a repeat ask, so much so that I only bought butterscotch this year!