Skip to main content


(180 reviews) Write a Review
1.25 LBS

Our Butterscotch Peanut Butter is made with roasted peanuts and butterscotch pieces. Try spreading this on top of a piece of pound cake for a tasty snack!
Serving Size - 2 Tablespoons
Ingredients: Dry Roasted Peanuts, Butterscotch Drops, Brown Sugar, Natural Flavor, Soybean Oil.


180 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5

    Posted by Linda Santucci on 17th Nov 2020

    Devine! But, hard to out that spoon down!

  • 5
    Butterscotch Peanutbutter

    Posted by Tara Reed on 12th Nov 2020

    Absolutely the best peanut butter out there. I eat everyday. Either on toast, ice cream, or just a spoonful to eat by itself. I’ve used it it baking and it adds a nice flavor and texture. Love it!

  • 5

    Posted by Stacy Scott on 8th Nov 2020

    great flavor.... not too sweet! will def purchase again !!!!

  • 5
    Best EVER!

    Posted by Unknown on 3rd Nov 2020

    I was visiting a friend who lives in N Cape May and she brought me downtown to shop at all the neat stores when we came across the PB shop I was so excited. I’d never heard of butterscotch peanut butter and knew I had to try it. OMG, it did not disappoint. It has become my new favorite and I have ordered twice online. I don’t think I can ever go back to regular old PB!

  • 5

    Posted by Katy on 29th Oct 2020

    Sweet and a little crunchy. I love it with apples - or right out of the jar! Great way to satisfy your sweet tooth while getting a good amount of proteins and healthy fats. Still a treat - but better for you!

  • 5
    Butterscotch peanut butter

    Posted by bob on 28th Sep 2020

    Absolutely the best! This is by far the best peanut butter that I have ever tasted. Not just the butterscotch flavor, but others as well. The cappuccino peanut butter is my all-time favorite. If you have been tested Cape May peanut butter, you’re missing something really special.

  • 5
    Great Taste

    Posted by Len Lyons on 25th Sep 2020

    If you love the taste of Butterscotch you will love this product. I keep ordering it even though the shipping is almost as much as the cost of the product. Only problem I have had is that their filling machine can leave a large air space in the jar. When I complained, they sent me a new jar free of charge and shipping.

  • 5
    best peanut butter ever

    Posted by Branden Bouchard on 5th Sep 2020

    amazing worth the cost gonna make a subscription if i can perfect for desserts.

  • 5
    The best tasting peanut butter ever

    Posted by Josh on 30th Aug 2020

    My family and I got this peanut butter for the first time in Cape May this summer and I was hooked. It's sweeter than standard PB and tastes so good with everything. 1 month later and I was ordering more for delivery. Has a great texture (not too smooth, but no full nuts), nice about of oils (its amazing warm) and a mild butterscotch flavor. Order some with the standard honey roasted and you'll be set for any PB occasion