(231 reviews) Write a Review
1.25 LBS
Adding to cart… The item has been added

Our Butterscotch Peanut Butter is made with roasted peanuts and butterscotch pieces. Try spreading this on top of a piece of pound cake for a tasty snack!

231 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Butterscotch Peanut Butter

    Posted by Lisa Capone on 30th Sep 2021

    My favorite peanut butter from Cape May! It’s great with bananas, apples, with jelly or jam or just to eat right out of the jar!

  • 5
    butter scotch butter

    Posted by ANNA P PACE on 30th Sep 2021

    It is so delicious. I definitely recommend it., you won't be disappointed.

  • 5
    Butterscotch pb

    Posted by Cynthia Teynolds on 29th Sep 2021

    Has become my very favorite snack. Love using it to bake cookies…. Anytime I can … I grab a tspn. And go for it!

  • 5
    Butterscotch peanut butter

    Posted by Heather on 22nd Sep 2021

    Excellent product! My whole family loves this! Perfect amount of flavors to make any recipe a hit!!

  • 5

    Posted by Kimberly Ann Parker on 21st Sep 2021

    This butterscotch peanut butter is the best peanut butter known to man. We cannot buy any other peanut butter because nothing compares to this greatness. We are absolutely hooked and will be lifelong customers. We also give this peanut butter away as a gift so others are aware peanut butter can really be that delicious. Absolutely AMAZING!!!!

  • 5
    Butterscotch is the best!

    Posted by Kimberly Postlewaite on 16th Sep 2021

    I don't know if this should be a warning or a review, but the butterscotch is highly addictive! So good!

  • 5
    Best Peanut butter

    Posted by Kelly Kevin on 15th Sep 2021

    I became aware of Cape May Peanut Butter Company about 3 years ago, and I no longer get peanut butter anywhere else. The taste and quality is amazing. The Butterscotch is to die for. Keeping portion sizes down is a challenge.

  • 5
    Best Peanut Butter

    Posted by Carmine Feola on 12th Aug 2021

    This is by far the best flavored peanut butter I’ve ever had!

  • 5
    Butter Scotch Peanut Butter

    Posted by Meghan Haldeman on 4th Aug 2021

    Always amazing!!