Showing reviews 1-10 of 101 | Next

1. Delish Butterscoth PB

   Posted by Kathy on 9th Apr 2019

   This is phenomenal butterscotch peanut butter. Everything I buy from Cape May Peanut-butter Company is phenomenal!

2. What a surprise!

   Posted by Craig Trampier on 2nd Apr 2019

   My wife has a new favorite peanut butter, and - you guessed it - this is it! There is no longer any such thing as pb&j at our house, only peanut butter from Peanut Butter Company.

3. capemay peanutbutter butterscotch

   Posted by Unknown on 10th Mar 2019

   great taste!

4. Best Peanut Butter Ever

   Posted by Unknown on 4th Mar 2019

   I have always loved butterscotch but this butterscotch peanut butter takes that love to a whole new level, so fresh and positively delicious!!!

5. Best peanut butter ever

   Posted by Courtney Debes on 13th Feb 2019

   Best peanut butter around

6. Amazingly Delicious

   Posted by Unknown on 12th Feb 2019

   Had my first...second...third...tastes of this delicious peanut butter. How on earth did I miss out on this all these years?? Quite frankly, it is addictive!!

7. A Flavor To Make You Cry!

   Posted by Debra Arnold on 5th Feb 2019

   First tasted this while staying in a bed and breakfast in Historic Smithville and loved it!!!! So, was excited to get my order online. Shared with my daughters and granddaughters. It made my little one actually cry it was so good.

8. peanut butter meets sweet

   Posted by Unknown on 18th Jan 2019

   This peanut butter has the perfect combination with the sweetness of the butterscotch. It tastes great at room temperature and in the refrigerator. I love using it on a sandwich or taking a spoonful.

9. favorite pb

   Posted by Kenneth L Wallen on 17th Jan 2019

   When I'm visiting Smithville village I always stop by Peanut Butter company and grab my favorite pb butterscotch!!!

10. Tasty....

    Posted by Michael King on 2nd Jan 2019

    Great PB ....the butterscotch is a different twist. Its delicious. Creamy fresh... Love how much more creamier and still lil chunky .... has a gteat texture. Phenomenal.

Showing reviews 1-10 of 101 | Next