Showing reviews 1-10 of 76 | Next

1. Can’t get enough

   Posted by Carleen Francisco on 24th Jun 2020

   This is mine & my son’s favorite. Every year we stock up while on vacation, this year had to order by mail and I’m glad I did. Yummy

2. THIS IS THE BEST

   Posted by Lauren S on 8th Jun 2020

   IMO this is THE BEST peanut butter sold by Cape May PB (except the Choc Choc, but that's more chocolate than PB, which isn't a bad thing!), and I eat it with everything. It's not too coffee-like, so don't worry about that. it's just downright delicious!

3. The Best

   Posted by Unknown on 29th May 2020

   Even though all of the flavors available are delicious, Cappuccino is my FAVORITE. My husband surprised me with an order for Mother's Day and I ate it so quick I had to place another order two weeks later. My favorite way to eat it is right from the jar. =)

4. Love Cape may peanut butter

   Posted by Unknown on 2nd May 2020

   I have been ordering Cape May peanut butters for the past 2 years .
   My absolute favorites are Cappuccino- leaves a fresh coffee aftertaste and Natural peanut butter .

5. Its too good

   Posted by Dan on 29th Apr 2020

   I bough some from the Smithville store once, and made the mistake of letting my wife try it. Now we have have at least 32 oz on hand at all times. It is a dietary staple in our household.

6. OMG

   Posted by Unknown on 24th Apr 2020

   I can’t stay out of the jar. I just eat it by the spoonfuls. Delish ❤️❤️

7. Best Peanut Butter Ever!

   Posted by Unknown on 24th Apr 2020

   Your product is delicious and was a big hit with the whole family! Thank you so much! Job well done!

8. Sooo Good !

   Posted by Tina Sniadowski on 4th Apr 2020

   I have turned my family on to this product and everyone loves it.

9. THE BEST EVER

   Posted by Donna R on 29th Mar 2020

   I am a peanut butter lover. I have had many brands and types . This is absolutely the best I’ve ever had!
   
   Can’t resist especially when there is free shipping.

10. Good to shop locally!

    Posted by Jacquie on 29th Mar 2020

    It's nice to find good artisan products at a decent price. I often visited the shop in Historic Smithville, but I'm glad to find that I can order online as well. The product is one of the best peanut butters I've tasted, and I enjoy trying the different varieties.

Showing reviews 1-10 of 76 | Next