Showing reviews 1-10 of 98 | Next

1. best peanut butter ever!!!!!

   Posted by Jamie McHenry on 5th Dec 2018

   The best!!! Love this place

2. So delicious!

   Posted by Sandra Oechslin on 6th Nov 2018

   My family loves this peanut butter! We bought some at the Smithville store this summer and just had to order more. It's great by itself or on semolina wheat crostini!

3. Heaven comes to Cape May

   Posted by Sam Latini on 28th Sep 2018

   The honey roasted peanut butter has a sweet, smooth taste, easy to spread on crackers or a toasted bagel. It doesn’t have that oil seperation like the organic peanut I’ve been buying. I’m happy that shipping is available with a wide variety of flavors available. As a peanut butter lover since childhood, I must say that it’s the best I’ve ever tasted.
   
   
   
   
   
   
   

4. Honey Roasted Heaven

   Posted by Marie Scarpias on 1st Sep 2018

   Tried this little hidden gem on a day trip to Cale May and planned a trip back just for the peanut butter. Found it online and now our life is complete. Just scrumptious...true honey roasted peanut flavor.

5. tastes just like honey roasted peanuts!

   Posted by Unknown on 27th Aug 2018

   So good.

6. Spreading the Love

   Posted by Sherry on 5th Jul 2018

   Every time I am in Cape May I bring back CM peanut butter for family and friends who can't wait to get it. Honey Roast is the flavor of choice for everyone. I love many of the flavors but this flavor is the go-to choice that pleases everyone!

7. Best overall

   Posted by Debbie on 25th Jun 2018

   Bought this a while ago for my (adult) kids to try and they loved it. When it ran out they tried other brands, not even close, this was by far the best Honey Roast they had ever had! Worth it to wait for the order to come in :)

8. Heaven on earth.

   Posted by Attilio on 11th Jun 2018

   Just turned 65. I will continue to eat this honey roasted until I die, and then I will order from heaven!

9. AWESOME PEANUT BUTTER

   Posted by Patricia Hamilton on 29th May 2018

   I wouldn't consider purchase of peanut butter from anywhere but Cape May, the best flavor, creamiest I have ever eaten! I eat it by the spoonful most every day, always purchase the large jar, 2 at a time! I add it to my breakfast oatmeal, extra protein to jump-start the day!

10. One of my Favorites

    Posted by Doug and Frank Bork-Wojnar on 24th May 2018

    a couple of weeks ago my Partner and I were in Cape May and we stopped by your store and we tested the Honey Roast Peanut Butter and we immediately fell in love with it. It is one of our favorites brands and we now HOOKED on it.

Showing reviews 1-10 of 98 | Next