Skip to main content


(197 reviews) Write a Review
1.25 LBS

This is our #1 selling Nut Butter! Eat it by the spoonful or put with anything you can imagine using peanut butter on! This is a great nut butter for anything!

Serving Size - 2 Tablespoons
Ingredients: USA Peanuts, Honey, Sugar and Love.



197 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    The BEST peanut butter!

    Posted by Unknown on 28th Oct 2020

    This is hands down, the best peanut butter I've ever eaten. I call it my "spoon peanut butter"-- it's best eaten with a spoon straight from the jar!

  • 5
    Peanut Butter Lovers, Look No Further!

    Posted by Carol G Giles on 26th Oct 2020

    A friend recommended Cape May to me so I ordered in a couple of small containers of peanut butter to try. The honey roasted is one of the best peanut butters that I have ever tasted. I highly recommend it! The cinnamon honey is a must try if you are a honey lover! Shipping was fast and efficient. This is a gem of a company so tell your friends!!!

  • 5
    Best Peanut Butter we’ve ever tasted!

    Posted by Amy on 16th Oct 2020

    We’re so happy we stopped into this little shop in Smithville, NJ recently! We purchased three small containers of different nut spreads, however, the Honey Roast was by far our favorite!! My family almost finished the container the first night we opened it! We were thrilled to learn that we could restock our supply by ordering more online and did not hesitate. This flavor is heavenly!! Thank you for making something so delicious and shipping it out to us so quickly....simple pleasures mean everything these days and we’re savoring every taste of this peanut butter!

  • 5
    Thiis peanut butter is like none other!

    Posted by Laura on 11th Oct 2020

    I have always enjoyed my store bought specialty peanut butter., but no more. I bought the honey roast peanut butter and it is so delicious that I can not go back to my regular peanut butter purchases. I now purchase Cape May Peanut butter on line and have it shipped to my home. Thank you for making the best peanut butter I have ever tasted

  • 5
    love this peanut butter

    Posted by Michael on 2nd Oct 2020

    I really do not eat peanut butter but in trying this, i am definitely a fan for life

  • 5
    Amazing Product!!!!

    Posted by helayne rojas on 10th Sep 2020

    This was the best natural peanut butter we ever had! So fresh and delicious too! Will order again and give away some for the holidays.

  • 5
    Great product

    Posted by Lisa on 1st Sep 2020

    best ever

  • 5
    best peanut butter ive ever had

    Posted by Dave on 1st Sep 2020

    Seriously this is the best peanut butter I’ve ever had. I’m obsessed. The consistency and taste are out of this world

  • 5
    A Tasty Treat

    Posted by Unknown on 26th Aug 2020

    I have enjoyed this product for the past few years. It great as a snack and is very tasty. Yummy! However, on my last order I ordered three 32 oz jars. One jar arrived half full. Disappointing.