(68 reviews) Write a Review
1.25 LBS
Adding to cart… The item has been added

Our Natural Peanut Butter is made with dry roasted peanuts and salt. Great for baking, smoothies, and much more!

Serving Size - 2 Tablespoons
Ingredients: Dry Roasted Peanuts, Salt.

68 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Natural peanut buttet

    Posted by Michael Stanton on 4th May 2021

    The best peanut butter we have had. Tried it during shop small and have been ordering ever since.

  • 5
    Natural Peanut Butter

    Posted by Christina Bolopue on 26th Apr 2021

    Delicious and creamy... easy to spread!!! My gripe other natural peanut butters.

  • 5
    The Best Peanut Butter on the Planet

    Posted by Ron on 19th Apr 2021

    Every single peanut butter Cape May makes is exceptional. It’s hard to pick my favorite because it is hard to choose between degrees of wonderful. I am somewhat of a peanut butter connoisseur and there is none better than those made by Cape May.

  • 5
    My favorite peanut butter

    Posted by Maria parkhill on 2nd Apr 2021

    I keep reordering this peanut butter because I live the flavor with the perfect amount of salt and the consistency is amazing!! Just like freshly ground peanuts!!

  • 5
    Peanut Butter

    Posted by Billene A Sherbocker on 29th Mar 2021

    Love this peanut butter. great texture, and taste. After trying CM p-butter I am spoiled for any other kind. Its great. Thanks

  • 5
    Natural Peanut Butter

    Posted by Bruce Kulpan on 23rd Mar 2021

    Love the fresh, just made flavor of this mighty tasty peanut butter!!!

  • 5
    Cape May Natural Peanut Butter

    Posted by Barbara on 2nd Mar 2021

    I’m 71 and have tried MANY different types of peanut butter. I “accidentally” discovered Cape May Peanut Butter last year. I can’t rave enough about it. The texture is perfect as I like crunchy, the peanuts used are exceptional, the amount of salt is just right and it needs no refrigeration, which is great. I have re-ordered several times, I’m turning my friends on to it and I’m a consumer for life!

  • 5
    Cape May Natural PeanutButter

    Posted by Charles Pruitt on 25th Feb 2021

    Every bit as good as advertised, used especially for our little dog who has diabetes because of its low sugar content. I sneak a little bite and it is delicious, really peanut buttery.

  • 5
    Best Peanut Butter

    Posted by Kelly Kevin on 18th Feb 2021

    This is the best peanut butter I have ever bought. Very fresh. It is important to stir the oil periodically into the peanut butter so the bottom doesn't dry out.