Showing reviews 1-10 of 33 | Next

1. THE BEST NATURAL PEANUT BUTTER!!!!

   Posted by Susan Cline on 16th Dec 2019

   I've been eating only natural peanut butter for about a year now. While on vacation this past June I forgot to pack my peanut butter. Lucky for me we spent a day in Cape May and I found The Peanut Butter Co! LOVE this Natural Peanut Butter so much!! I refuse to eat any other brand now!! I highly recommend it to all peanut butter lovers like me!

2. Love it !!

   Posted by Marc Press on 19th Nov 2019

   Best peanut better ever!l no other is even close!

3. TOP SHELF!

   Posted by Joseph on 15th Nov 2019

   This is THE BEST PEANUT BUTTER I have EVER tasted and I'm 73 years old.

4. yum

   Posted by Unknown on 13th Nov 2019

   Had this during the summer. Had to order more! So tasty!!!

5. Beat Peanut Butter on the Planet

   Posted by Maria H on 11th Nov 2019

   This is the beat peanut butter I have ever tasted. I originally tried it because it didn’t have any added sugar. The flavor is amazing and the textures is very good. Don’t stop making this because I won’t be able to eat any other peanut butters again.

6. Great Peanut Butter

   Posted by Gregg on 3rd Nov 2019

   Love this Peanut Butter. Great consistency and not too sweet. I found the shop on a recent trip to Cape May and now I order online.

7. LOVE CAPE MAY PEANUT BUTTER

   Posted by JOAN QUINN on 24th Oct 2019

   HAVE HAD THIS MANY TIMES, CAPE MAY FERRY STARTED ME ON THIS. MADE A TRIP FROM STATEN ISLAND NEW YORK TO CAPE MAY FOR THIS

8. Love this peanut butter!!

   Posted by Lisa on 10th Oct 2019

   We are Peanut Butter lovers and have tried many different brands. We bought our first container while visiting Cape May and now order online because it’s all we want to eat.

9. Best Peanut Butter on the Planet

   Posted by Jack Szydloski on 30th Sep 2019

   Didn't know Peanut Butter could be so could. This stuff is the caviar of peanut butters. It's so good, we eat it with a spoon sometimes. I'd have it for my last meal! Get some!

10. Terrific

    Posted by Dave on 7th Aug 2019

    We came across this peanut butter company when my wife was on vacation. She brought it home to her favorite peanut butter lover (me) and it knocked me off my feet. I've been ordering here and there as a treat for years now.

Showing reviews 1-10 of 33 | Next