Skip to main content


(52 reviews) Write a Review
1.25 LBS

Our Natural Peanut Butter is made with dry roasted peanuts and salt. Great for baking, smoothies, and much more!

Serving Size - 2 Tablespoons
Ingredients: Dry Roasted Peanuts, Salt.

52 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    So good, i ordered 6 jars!

    Posted by suzyofnyc on 20th Oct 2020

    I always get a jar of Cape May peanut butter when I visit, but once home, I realized how much I love it, especially for lunches as I work from home. I ordered 6 jars for my wfh stash! A little Cape May every day is the best!

  • 5

    Posted by Damon on 13th Oct 2020

    I have never, ever liked peanut butter. I'm in my mid 30's, I've tried peanut butter hundreds, thousands of times and never liked it. But my girlfriend picked up a jar of Natural Peanut Butter in Cape May over the summer and I'm hooked. It is a totally different product than I've been trying my whole life. This product has changed my opinion of peanut butter. I love it so much, I bought the honey peanut butter and now I'm hooked on that! You are clearly making a more elevated product than anything I've ever tried. Perhaps most importantly, you helped me feel like a kid again. I never had snacks with peanut butter growing up because I didn't like peanut butter. But now that I LOVE your product, eating it makes me feel like I'm regaining a piece of my youth. Thanks.

  • 5

    Posted by Kathy on 10th Oct 2020

    Tastes so good on apples and bananas. The best PB sandwich ever.

  • 5
    Loved it

    Posted by Marge Miller on 6th Oct 2020

    The best peanut butter

  • 5
    Best natural peanut buttter ever

    Posted by lisa on 28th Sep 2020

    delicious, we love it

  • 5
    the best

    Posted by Sheryl Gemmill on 12th Aug 2020

    I LOVE peanut butter, but omg....Cape May PB is the best! It's that whipped texture that I's not condensed, nor oily.

  • 5
    Natural peanut butter is the best

    Posted by Maribeth Pete on 8th Aug 2020

    I purchase the Natural Peanut Butter several times a year, my kids love it over any other kind. They are always asking when I will be buying it again! The best!

  • 5
    Delicious and healthy

    Posted by CP Girl on 6th Aug 2020

    Maintains good consistency pretty much to the end; is delicious and really low in sugar, only 1 gram per serving.

  • 5
    Just Right

    Posted by Unknown on 27th Jun 2020

    Not too salty. Not too sweet. Not soupy. Just Right!