Showing reviews 1-10 of 24 | Next

1. Terrific

   Posted by Dave on 7th Aug 2019

   We came across this peanut butter company when my wife was on vacation. She brought it home to her favorite peanut butter lover (me) and it knocked me off my feet. I've been ordering here and there as a treat for years now.

2. OUTSTANDING

   Posted by Perry Mayers on 18th Apr 2019

   Maybe the best pure peanut butter I've ever eaten. As the label says...nothing but Peanut Butter and a touch of Sea Salt. None of the sugars and other added Ingredients you get with the store bought brands.

3. Best Peanut Butter

   Posted by WILLIAM F COWEN on 18th Jan 2019

   Love the CMPB peanut butter, great texture and excellent taste

4. Best Peanut Butter Ever

   Posted by Elizabeth Loew on 14th Jan 2019

   Delicious. We were introduced to this peanut butter in the fall, as a gift. We have since received more (as a gift) and ordered more for ourselves. It's absolutely worth the additional price of shipping. We have tried Honey Roasted, Chocolate, and Natural. All delicious. Highly recommend on sandwiches, and on fruit.

5. THE BEST

   Posted by Linda Kells on 20th Dec 2018

   Cape May Peanut Butter's Natural Peanut Butter is hands down the best. I have tried others, but they don't even measure up. It has just the right amount of salt and perfect texture. I order the 32 oz. size on line (2 and 3 at a time) so I don't have to worry about running out.

6. Delicious

   Posted by Maureen on 11th Dec 2018

   I love peanut butter and this is the best. It tastes wonderful and doesn't separate as other natural brands do. I bought some in the store on a trip to Cape May in October and have since ordered it online. It ships quickly and arrives promptly.

7. THE BEST Peanut Butter

   Posted by Unknown on 24th Oct 2018

   Bought a small jar when my boyfriend and I were on vacation in a Cape May and have already ordered two more large jars! Will NEVER go back to Jif...this peanut butter and some crackers has become my favorite snack

8. the best peanut butter ever!

   Posted by Patricia on 19th Sep 2018

   I only eat all natural peanut butter, I have tried many! This is by far the best I’ve ever had, I will never be without it!

9. Just can't keep it in stock!

   Posted by Joanne Kurteson on 13th Sep 2018

   Stumbled upon your store a few years ago and have been ordering your natural peanut butter ever since. My grown children love it as much as I do and I order 5 at a time every few months! Thank you for such a great product!

10. delicious fresh peanut butter

    Posted by Unknown on 26th Jun 2018

    The quality of this peanut butter is in its own class.
    The texture and taste is the best

Showing reviews 1-10 of 24 | Next