(65 reviews) Write a Review
1.25 LBS
Adding to cart… The item has been added

Our Natural Peanut Butter is made with dry roasted peanuts and salt. Great for baking, smoothies, and much more!

Serving Size - 2 Tablespoons
Ingredients: Dry Roasted Peanuts, Salt.

65 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Natural Peanut

    Posted by Gerardo on 3rd Feb 2021

    I love this PB because it’s ingredients are only peanuts and salt —sugar or hydrogenated vegetable oil like most store brands. Also, unlike most “natural” peanut butters I’ve had in the past, you don’t constantly have to stir oil back into it. It maintains its consistency. Excellent product.

  • 5
    Natural peanut butter is the best

    Posted by Marybeth Huber on 1st Feb 2021

    No comparison, it is the best!

  • 5
    Great peanut butter

    Posted by Maria on 26th Jan 2021

    We love the natural flavor and perfect amount of salt and consistency of this peanut butter

  • 5
    Natural peanutbutter

    Posted by JanetD on 20th Jan 2021

    I love their peanut butter. Very tasty, crunchy. I use it for PB&J and also in my Thai food., spicy peanut sauce and Pat Thai. Mmm.

  • 5
    So good, i ordered 6 jars!

    Posted by suzyofnyc on 20th Oct 2020

    I always get a jar of Cape May peanut butter when I visit, but once home, I realized how much I love it, especially for lunches as I work from home. I ordered 6 jars for my wfh stash! A little Cape May every day is the best!

  • 5

    Posted by Damon on 13th Oct 2020

    I have never, ever liked peanut butter. I'm in my mid 30's, I've tried peanut butter hundreds, thousands of times and never liked it. But my girlfriend picked up a jar of Natural Peanut Butter in Cape May over the summer and I'm hooked. It is a totally different product than I've been trying my whole life. This product has changed my opinion of peanut butter. I love it so much, I bought the honey peanut butter and now I'm hooked on that! You are clearly making a more elevated product than anything I've ever tried. Perhaps most importantly, you helped me feel like a kid again. I never had snacks with peanut butter growing up because I didn't like peanut butter. But now that I LOVE your product, eating it makes me feel like I'm regaining a piece of my youth. Thanks.

  • 5

    Posted by Kathy on 10th Oct 2020

    Tastes so good on apples and bananas. The best PB sandwich ever.

  • 5
    Loved it

    Posted by Marge Miller on 6th Oct 2020

    The best peanut butter

  • 5
    Best natural peanut buttter ever

    Posted by lisa on 28th Sep 2020

    delicious, we love it