Skip to main content


(52 reviews) Write a Review
1.25 LBS

Our Natural Peanut Butter is made with dry roasted peanuts and salt. Great for baking, smoothies, and much more!

Serving Size - 2 Tablespoons
Ingredients: Dry Roasted Peanuts, Salt.

52 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5

    Posted by Lori Kendall on 21st Jun 2020

    The absolute best peanut butter I have ever eaten!

  • 5
    Love Cape may peanut butter

    Posted by Unknown on 2nd May 2020

    The first time I tried Cape May peanut butter, I fell in love with it . This is the only peanut butter I buy And I have been ordering it for the past two years .

  • 5

    Posted by on 23rd Apr 2020

    We always stop in to the store when we are in Cape May. We wanted the store brought to us in this covid time. Nothing but delicious and fresh tasting!

  • 5
    I just keep coming back!

    Posted by Reese on 22nd Apr 2020

    Still the best-tasting peanut butter. Wished we lived closer.

  • 5

    Posted by Stacey on 20th Apr 2020

    Always great quality

  • 5

    Posted by chuck on 16th Apr 2020

    This is the place if your a peanut butter head

  • 5
    Great Taste

    Posted by Sean Coons on 28th Feb 2020

    For a "normal" flavor, it is so good. Takes natural peanut to a new level

  • 5
    Yummy healthfulness

    Posted by Unknown on 10th Feb 2020

    Since awakening to the added sugar in most commercial peanut butters, I found and switched to Cape May brand. Now my favorite town has my favorite peanut butter.

  • 5
    The best peanut butter ever!

    Posted by Unknown on 3rd Feb 2020

    Cape May Peanut Butter never disappoints!