(83 reviews) Write a Review
1.25 LBS
Adding to cart… The item has been added

Our Natural Peanut Butter is made with dry roasted peanuts and salt. Great for baking, smoothies, and much more!

83 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    Best peanut butter ever!

    Posted by Laraine on 2nd Aug 2021

    That's it! It's the GOAT!

  • 5
    Best Peanut Butter

    Posted by Jackie Rubin on 12th Jul 2021

    I love this peanut butter. It is delicious! It tastes fresh and flavorful. Never oily.

  • 5
    Cape May Natural Peanut Butter

    Posted by Charles Pruitt on 7th Jul 2021

    I buy this product 3 16oz jars at a time to give to my dog who has diabetes, this product is better for him than the brand name products that have way too much sugar and stuff. Plus he loves it and I do too!

  • 5
    This ends the peanut butter debate

    Posted by Dan Robinson on 6th Jul 2021

    My family generally eats healthy as my wife is a professional dietitian. However, she, my 2 teenage sons and I can never agree on a peanut butter brand and we often have at least 4 open jars of different brands in the cupboard. A few weeks ago my wife and I did a day trip to Cape May and bought a 32 ounce jar of the Natural Peanut Butter. This large jar lasted less than a week in my house (everyone loves it) and we already ordered (and received very quickly) 3 more jars! At first I was concerned because it seemed like it had to be more expensive than other brands. But if you do the math, it’s actually cheaper than competitive “natural” brands at places like Whole Foods, even with the shipping fee. We will be buying this peanut butter (exclusively) for many years to come.

  • 5
    Natural Peanut Butter

    Posted by Kat & Terry Larsen on 17th Jun 2021

    IT IS THE BEST! We were first introduced to your products, years ago when our Son and Daughter-in-Law, (she's a Jersey Girl), took us to Cape May. We are Peanut Butter enthusiasts. Cannot imagine life without your FABULOUS product. Thank you!!!

  • 5
    Very fresh & very good taste

    Posted by Deb Reese on 14th Jun 2021

    This product will be ordered again. Actually just finished ordering g a larger jar. Very fresh & very good

  • 5
    Natural peanut buttet

    Posted by Michael Stanton on 4th May 2021

    The best peanut butter we have had. Tried it during shop small and have been ordering ever since.

  • 5
    Natural Peanut Butter

    Posted by Christina Bolopue on 26th Apr 2021

    Delicious and creamy... easy to spread!!! My gripe other natural peanut butters.

  • 5
    The Best Peanut Butter on the Planet

    Posted by Ron on 19th Apr 2021

    Every single peanut butter Cape May makes is exceptional. It’s hard to pick my favorite because it is hard to choose between degrees of wonderful. I am somewhat of a peanut butter connoisseur and there is none better than those made by Cape May.