(25 reviews) Write a Review
1.25 LBS
Adding to cart… The item has been added

25 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    PB Review

    Posted by Margarita Maravel on 29th Dec 2021

    Absolutely the best! Love the crunchiness and that it is not salty.

  • 5
    Organic peanut butter

    Posted by Alice on 11th Oct 2021

    Absolutely love this product! Only contains peants and salt. There are no additives, oil or sugar in it. It is thick, with tiny pieces of peanuts and it is delicious. I ordered 2 large containers to be delivered because I could not make it to the Smithville shop!

  • 5
    Organic Peanut Butter

    Posted by Angela Bova on 2nd Sep 2021

    The most amazing fresh peanut butter. Trust me on this. Once you taste it, you won't want to have any other. It's almost whipped in a way but creamy and deliciously smooth but also a bit crunchy. It's the perfect blend of a crunchy and smooth peanut butter. The taste is seriously the best in terms of quality in comparison to other peanut butters I have tried (and I've tried many). It tastes deliciously roasted and fresh. The shipping was very quick too!

  • 5
    Organic Peanut Butter

    Posted by Mark Shermeyer on 19th Aug 2021

    Discovered this in Cape May and enjoy is so much that we have it shipped when we're not in Cape May so we have a continuous supply. Better and less oily than any comparative, natural brand we've found in stores. The entire family (and even the dogs!) really love it!

  • 5
    Organic Peanut

    Posted by Marie Morano on 14th Aug 2021


  • 5
    Excellent organic peanut butter

    Posted by Marie on 13th Nov 2020

    Very tasty and healthy

  • 5
    the best pranut butter ever!

    Posted by Lisa on 26th Aug 2020

    This is my favorite peanut butter of all time! I have tried a lot of others but nothing can compare. The only ingredient is peanuts! Perfect consistency. A little chunky not too much oil. Just perfect!

  • 5

    Posted by Kathy on 12th Aug 2020

    I order my nut butters from Cape May. No others compare. Thank You!

  • 5
    Smooth but chunky!

    Posted by Adele on 25th Jun 2020

    I just love this organic peanut butter! It is thick and smooth, but you can still see the small particles of peanuts in it. I love to take a spoonful of it in the afternoon as a snack. Yum! It's great on a toasted English muffin as well. This is just a great product!